April, I'm so sorry. I can "hear" the stress, frustration, and exhaustion in your words. I've been there and I know the level of exhaustion and "being at your wit's end" that you're feeling. My kids were miserable sleepers as infants and they didn't "whimper" either, they were the blood-curdling screamers that you mentioned with Malia. I was always so envious of people who said that their infants would wake during the night, whimper, fuss for a minute, and then go right back to sleep. My kids were not like that AT ALL as babies!!! (I nursed them each for a year.) I know that I don't know you, but I soooo feel your pain.
It sounds like you've ruled out most of the things that *may* be causing her to wake up. The rest of it is "unknowns". I guess teeth are always a factor at any age. I know that this is not always the most popular opinion, but I believe that around this age, children become "master manipulators". I am not suggesting that they have devious or evil intentions by any means, just that they learn how to "work the system" to their favor! Malia is a smarty-pants! She knows that the more she cries and the louder she cries and the longer she cries, eventually Mom will come and get her. She's no dummy!

The only thing that worked for my kids was CIO in order for me to regain my sanity! Literally, I felt like I was losing my mind! I know that you are not a fan of it and I COMPLETELY respect that. I'm just praying that someone has some really good suggestions for you because I have no other ideas. I wish I had some great words of wisdom....
Vent all you need to. And remember...."this too shall pass". It
will and it always
does. Hang in there, April! PM me if you ever need to talk.
